| Offence All Stars | Defence All Stars |
| Quarterback – Jason Ferreira, North Bay | Defensive Line – Brad Kerr, North Bay |
| Running Back – Sean Jacobs, Toronto Eagles | Defensive Line – Karl Kustor, Oakville |
| Running Back – Dan McAlonan, Oakville | Defensive Line – Dwayne Scott, Oakville |
| Receiver – Steve Asselin, North Bay | Defensive Line – Stu Waite, Sault Storm |
| Receiver – Gifford Rose, Toronto Eagles | Linebacker – Delroy George, Toronto Eagles |
| Receiver – Dave St. Amour, Sudbury | Linebacker – Stafford Wilson, Oakville |
| Receiver – Danny Bobb, Oakville * | Linebacker – Jeff Chalice, Peterborough * |
| Receiver – Mike Dingsdale, Oakville * | Linebacker – Darwin Renette, North Bay * |
| Offensive Line – Jim Canale, Toronto Eagles | Defensive Back – Ben Bolduc, Sault |
| Offensive Line – Nelson Cheechoo, North Bay | Defensive Back – Al Campbell, Oakville |
| Offensive Line – Jamie Coombs, Sault Storm | Defensive Back – Sonny Diduch, Toronto Eagles |
| Offensive Line – Craig Marshall, Oakville | Defensive Back – Mike Forth, North Bay |
| Offensive Line – Chris Nunn, Oakville | Defensive Back – Doug Steringa, Oakville |
| Special Teams | |
| Punter – Dana Segin, Oakville | Kicker – Jim McMillan, Peterborough |
| Punt Return – Gifford Rose, Markham | Kick Return – Dave St. Amour, Sudbury |
*Denotes tie for position